Who Actually Invented the Burger? Nobody Agrees, and That's the Fun Part

November 17, 2026•By Hader Suliman

Before the Bun, There Was Hamburg

The burger didn't start out as a sandwich. In 19th-century Hamburg, Germany, people ate a patty of minced beef on a plate, with a knife and fork. German immigrants carried the idea to the US, and port cities like New York picked it up.

So the meat was already here. It just hadn't met a bun yet. It also explains why a burger is named after a German city even though the sandwich itself was built in America.

Everyone Wants the Credit

Here are the main contenders.

  • Charlie Nagreen, Wisconsin, 1885. He was 15 and selling meatballs at the Seymour Fair, and they weren't exactly flying off the table. The story goes that he flattened one between two slices of bread so people could eat while they walked. Seymour now calls itself the Home of the Hamburger, and he's "Hamburger Charlie."

  • The Menches brothers, Ohio. Frank and Charles say they ran out of pork at a fair, got ground beef from the butcher instead, and named the sandwich after the town where they were selling it. Which fair, and which year, depends on who's telling it.

  • Fletcher "Old Dave" Davis, Texas, late 1880s. According to his family, he was a potter who ran a lunch stand when work was slow. He later took his burgers to the 1904 St. Louis World's Fair.

  • Louis Lassen, Connecticut, 1895 to 1900. The tale at his New Haven lunch wagon is that a customer in a hurry wanted lunch to go, so Lassen grilled some leftover steak trimmings and put them between two slices of toast.

If you want an official answer, the Library of Congress sides with Louis' Lunch in New Haven. The place is still open, still serves its burgers on toast, and is famous for not having ketchup.

That hasn't settled anything. Some historians say these early versions were just sandwiches, and most of the stories rest on family memory and local pride rather than paper records.

Our guess, and it's only a guess, is that nobody invented it. Busy people at fairs and lunch counters needed something they could eat on their feet, and a few cooks landed on the same answer around the same time.

Then Somebody Added Cheese

The cheeseburger shows up in the mid-1920s, and the usual credit goes to a teenager named Lionel Sternberger. He was working at his father's sandwich shop, The Rite Spot, in Pasadena, California, and supposedly dropped a slice of cheese on a sizzling patty just to see what would happen. The year changes depending on who you ask, anywhere from 1924 to 1927, and a few other restaurants claim it too.

My favorite footnote: in 1935, Louis Ballast of the Humpty Dumpty Drive-In in Denver got a trademark on the word "cheeseburger" and never enforced it. Lucky for the rest of us.

The Burger Gets a Makeover

It's easy to forget that for a while, Americans didn't trust ground beef. It had a reputation as cheap scrap meat.

In 1921, a cook named Walter Anderson and a businessman named Billy Ingram opened White Castle in Wichita, Kansas. They built small, spotless white buildings that looked like little castles, which was the whole idea: clean, solid, safe. The burgers were small, cheap and made the same way every time. Time magazine later called the White Castle slider the most influential burger of all time.

Then Everyone Copied It

After that, the burger spread fast. Drive-ins and roadside stands popped up all over America. In 1940, brothers Richard and Maurice McDonald opened a restaurant in San Bernardino, California, and in 1948 they cut the menu down and built the kitchen around speed, which they called the Speedee Service System. Ray Kroc bought the company rights later and grew it through franchising.

From there the burger went global and picked up local twists along the way: spicy sauces, fried eggs, pickles, halloumi. Every city seems to end up with its own version.

So Who Wins?

Honestly, we don't know. It could have been a teenager at a Wisconsin fair, a lunch-wagon cook in Connecticut, or a Texas potter flipping patties on the side. What's clear is that a German beef patty, a lot of hungry workers and a few clever cooks ended up with one of the most loved sandwiches around. That's a lot of history in one bite.

Your turn: classic and simple, or stacked as high as it'll go?

Reactions

Your Next Favorite Meal is One Tap Away

Download Pleny

Get the app and start connecting with foodies today

Download on App StoreGet it on Google Play